8.24.03
Smarts that smart
by Jon Worley

What do you get when your kid is a brat?
Pampered and spoiled like a Siamese cat
Blaming the child is a lie and a shame
You know exactly who's to blame:
The mother and the father

"Oompa-Loompa Song #3,"
Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory

There's this interesting myth that anyone who scores 1600 on the SAT can get into the college of his or her choice. There's also the myth that a earning a 1600 means you got every question right, but that's another story.

Down in these here parts there's a bit of a hullaballoo about this kid who scored a 1600, earned 24 hours of college credit during his senior year--including passing at least five advanced placement exams--is a National Merit Scholarship finalist and, oh, yeah, attempted to start his own computer software company. Not bad.

Mark Edmonson applied to a number of schools. MIT told him no, Babson put him on a wait list and the University of North Carolina said yes.

After getting accepted at UNC, Edmonson then went on to miss 18 days of school and score a 1.3 grade point average for his senior year, including failing computer science (this is the kid who tried to start his own software company, remember?) and getting a D in American history.

When UNC received his final grades, the admissions people became a wee bit concerned and asked Edmonson to make an accounting of himself. Apparently, the meeting did not go well. In a widely-quoted e-mail, associate director of admissions Herb Davis said "his poor mother had to try and save him before I bounced him out on his pious ass."

It is interesting to note that comments like that from UNC officials don't even raise an eyebrow around here. Carolina is a fine school, but like most excellent centers of learning it has a bit of an attitude. As does young Edmonson. When big egos clash, the bigger one almost always wins. Which meant that the kid never had a chance.

Anyway, UNC rescinded its admission offer and Edmonson sued. He lost the first round, and will not be allowed to attend class while the case works its way through the courts.

I see a couple of things happening here. First, there's the culture of hyper-achievement that surrounds kids at suburban high schools these days. Get good grades, do the "right" extracurricular activities, volunteer at the old folks home (it looks good on your application), take college course work on the side, etc., etc., etc. I think any rational person can see the lunacy of putting such pressure on teenagers who, if given any leeway whatsoever, would rather kick back with a couple beers and contemplate getting laid.

But more important to me is the issue of the parents. Edmonson's "poor" mother may have tried to help him in his meeting with UNC, but she obviously hadn't prepared him properly when he was growing up. If she (and his father) had done so, here's how all this would have transpired:

  • Edmonson receives "de-admission" letter from UNC and screams his fool head off. A perfectly natural and healthy expression of pain and anger.
  • A minute or so later, Edmonson calms down and begins preparing for his meeting with the admissions people.
  • At the meeting, Edmonson explains what happened and accepts full responsibility for his failure (Davis reports in his e-mail that Edmonson blamed one grade on a teacher who didn't like him), takes full responsibility and asks what he needs to do to get back into Carolina's good graces.
  • Davis then tells Edmonson to go to UNC-Greensboro for a semester or two, get Dean's List grades and then he'll be welcomed back with open arms.
  • Edmonson thanks Davis, then drives back home to Greensboro with his mom, stopping off at the UNC-G campus to sign up for classes.

    Notice I'm not ripping Davis or UNC for their admittedly high-handed approach to this. Certainly, there is more than a touch of arrogance involved in the way Davis and the admissions office handled this situation. Still, it is a privilege to attend college (even a public one), and Edmonson should have acted that way during his interview. Certainly he had no reason to believe that UNC owed him anything whatsoever.

    My parents taught me that when you're in high school, high school needs to be taken care of first. I hated my high school and started counting the days before I could escape the moment I walked in the door as a sophomore, but nonetheless I made sure to turn in all my assignments and study for tests (as much as necessary to get an A, anyway).

    If I were one of the folks at UNC, the 18 days missed would bother me more than the grades. What guarantee does Carolina have that Edmonson wouldn't get distracted by something else, skip out on a third of a semester and crash once more? None, if Davis's report of their meeting last month is at all accurate.

    Edmonson got ahead of himself, and his haste bit him in the ass. Maybe now he'll finally learn that he, too, has limitations and responsibilities. And maybe he'll figure out that life is about managing those responsibilities and limitations as well as following your dreams. Truly successful people can do all three and be happy at the same time.


    Jon Worley has never been kicked out of school or fired from a job, but that's not for lack of trying.


  • e-mail Jon Worley
    return to the Shut up, I'm talking page
    return to the LIES home page
    return to the A&A home page